This reading could give some reasonable clarity on:
1.
What actually caused the ISRO Spy
Scandal in 1994?
2.
How people are sacrificed to protect
the deep State secrets?
3. Why Kerala Press and media was/is not
objective in its reporting?
4.
How could a serious but unconnected
case make strange political connotations?
5.
How arrogance bring about one’s
downfall?
Due to limited global sanctions
against India on account of its un-allowed indulgence in Atomic energy sector, the
country faced many difficulties during 1970s and beyond. Thus, Indian space and
atomic energy institutions and establishments weren’t allowed to procure or
avail high-end technology gadgets & knowhow from outside, making it the
reason for India making its own super computer and reaching self-reliance in
harnessing the space and atomic energy technologies
As a part of it, Indian Space
Research Organisation (ISRO), was denied the know-how of cryogenic engine
technology, an integral part of India’s advanced GSLV project, which otherwise
would have come from Russia, that stood as a stumbling block to the progress of
nation’s space research programs.
To overcome this, with the blessing
and permission from the powers that be, Indian scientists used some clandestine
methods to gain access to this technology from Russia, of course, with the
Russian establishment closing its eyes. The act was to bring some of the second
rung space scientists from Russia and work with them at Trivandrum labs of ISRO
(with VSSC, LPSC and other bull-work of the space research happening in
Trivandrum). Nambi Narayanan, being the leader of the research project at ISRO,
was entrusted with the responsibility of looking after the scientists here at
TVM that included their work, stay, food, entertainment & Vodka (remember,
they were Russians !). He was allocated unaccounted funds for that. The
scientists were staying in Trivandrum as tourists.
Nambi Narayanan (NN) was one of the
reckoned top scientists in ISRO at that time, the face of the cryogenic
technology and the blue eyed boy of the bosses. Naturally, things had gone into
his head and many times he was showing this off, making more enemies than friends
within, something that had resulted in him getting ostracised from fraternity,
after his downfall.
Naturally, these Russian scientists
were here on clandestine mission for helping India acquire the cryogenic engine
technology. Staying in guest houses and hotels, they were getting deprived of
the physiological necessity of sex. Hearing it, and in order to keep their
spirits high, NN decided on to organise this service for them in
Trivandrum.
During those days (80s & 90s),
Trivandrum had been the Switzerland for Maldivians, having direct flight
connection. Most of their health issues were resolved in Trivandrum hospitals
like Cosmopolitan, GG, SUT etc. Some of the impoverished but smart ladies from
Maldives also came in and utilised the opportunity to make money by providing
sex to locals and the tourists coming to TVM. Mariam Rasheeda (MR) was one such
person and her ‘handler’ was Fouziya Hassan, another middle aged Maldivian women.
MR by then had acquired star reputation as one who provide more bang
for the buck, and a very co-operative professional in the trade.
MR, based on the invitation from NN’s
connect, started giving the required services to the Russian ‘tourists’, on high
periodicity, and she was very talented. She knew she was servicing some real VVIPs
of the State, under the knowledge of Police & top officials.
It is only genuine to surmise that
the then Kerala Chief Minister, K Karunakaran and some key Police officials had
known the story, at least vaguely, and the reason for the Russians staying in Trivandrum.
All was going well but an incident
brought the plot into the open. MR went to the office of the Special branch
Police to get her Visa extended. As she had established good traction with the
powers in police by then, (it wasn’t the first time that she was extending her
Visa) she behaved little arrogantly with Mr. Vijayan, the police officer there.
Vijayan could not appreciate her arrogance and he not only didn’t give her the
extension but went on to check her antecedents and things started falling into
the open, in bits and pieces.
The powers be of the deep State, who
knew the actual truth, kept quiet and acted as if they knew nothing. Most
important aspect was that under no circumstances the country wanted the truth to
come out, because it would have created such furore across the globe, and against
an existing limited global sanction, the country’s clandestine act with Russian
scientist would have put it into extremely bad situation as an offender/defaulter
leading to international embarrassment and higher sanctions, such as economic
blockade etc. While the truth was
hidden, The Russians ’tourists’ were quickly picked up and packed off to their country. Typical case as how the deep State would act to protect its
official secrets.
Unbeknown, the local police went
ahead with the interrogation of MR and she spilled whatever she knew. The police
registered a prostitution case with connection to senior ISRO scientists and concocted
a spy story with NN and his deputy, Sasikumaran trying to sell space technology
to the foreigners, luring the clients with sex from international escorts, and
by taking help of some ISRO contractors. The story got leaked (?) to the press
& media, and without doing any proper fact check, the media connected the
itsy-bitsy pieces and came out with an international spy scandal of science,
sex & sedition. It wouldn’t be an overstatement that Kerala press &
media, in it’s over enthusiasm, was instrumental in complicating the story,
particularly with the sex content it (as we see later in Saritha, Swapna cases
etc.) See how a small sexual gratification case has become that of sedition and
treason, and the role of press & media in inflating ordinary story to a
larger context.
With MR already in, in Novemeber
1994, the police arrested NN, Sasikumaran, Fouzziya Hassan & two
businessmen from Bangalore; M/s. Chandrasekharan & Sharma [ISRO head office
being in Bangalore, these two were engaged in supply of materials to ISRO and
based on request from scientists from ISRO, they did some favours to Fouzziya
Hassan in getting admission for her daughters to some premium schools in Bangalore].
They had undergone heavy physical torture at the hands of police during the interrogation
(which included the local office of a central agency, the Intelligence Bureau -IB-
too). It is learnt later that the torture was such a third degree one, in order
to save the life, they all signed the confession
Using the spy scandal story, some
disgruntled senior members within the ruling Congress party (which always
suffered from inner party politics) led by AK Antony, Oommen Chandy et al; who
were looking for an opportunity to get even with Chief Minister Karunakaran, found
a political opportunity to displace the chief minister, whom they hated. By somehow
connecting him into the sedition scandal and with the help of media, using such
imaginative, titillating stories, they succeeded in getting him to resign. They
also tried to implicate IG of Police, Raman Shrivastava who was very close to
Karunakaran, in the case. All the while, notice that the deep state had
been indifferent to the innocence of people.
AK Antony, the receiver of the
political windfall, came in as CM in place of Karunakaran, appointed Siby
Mathews IPS as the Head of Special Investigations team of the ISRO Spy case.
Mathews in collaboration with the IB local head, went on the rampage with the
vengeance of a man possessed (a curious case of someone more loyal to the
nation than the king himself!), to implicate everyone but without solid
evidence. Due to public and opposition party pressure, by the end of the year,
the state police handed over the case to Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) who
did not find any evidence in the case and the court set the defendants free. This
also is a typical example of an unconnected case acquiring political
dimensions, thereby destroying the political career of a strong leader of the
state. In politics, you wouldn’t know where the hit comes from!
The Communist party chief Minister,
Nayanar who came into power later, reopened the case with another police team.
NN approached the high court which rejected his appeal, upon which he moved the
Supreme Court. In 1998, the CBI submitted a secret report to Supreme Court along
with the final report of the case. The confidential report purportedly listed
the investigative flaws committed by the investigating officers, the then
Additional Director General of Police (ADGP) Siby Mathews, and Superintendents
of Police K. K. Joshua and S. Vijayan. In 1998, the SC struck down the HC
judgement and ordered a compensation of ₹1 lakh to all the accused
Thereafter, NN went on to file for
compensation for the agonies suffered by him and he approached High court &
Supreme Court as well as the Human Rights commission. From all places, high
amounts of compensation orders were issued in his favour. He is still fighting
a criminal case against the erring police officials requesting the Court to
take punitive action against them.
Lastly, arrogance had played a key
role in the negative development of the case. The first is that of Nambi
Narayanan, while he was getting tortured and getting stamped as a traitor,
losing his job and all the benefits associated with it & family undergoing
extreme difficulties; no one from the ISRO or even his colleagues, came forward
to help him. It could be said that no one wanted to be involved in this case of
sedition, so they kept off. But it must also be noted that his highhanded arrogance
also played a role in people not feeling like helping him.
And for Mariam Rasheeda, had she kept
her cool when she came to renew her visa, by not showing off in front of the
Police officer, no one would have heard the case at all. This again is another
example of arrogance bringing the downfall
***